Should You Refinance Your Mortgage?

August 24, 2020

On March 15, The Federal Reserve dropped the federal funds rate to 0-0.25%, which then sent average mortgage rates to 50-year lows, with an average 30-year mortgage around 3% (Source: FreddieMac.com).


So what does this mean for someone with a mortgage? When does it make sense to refinance?


There are two rules of thumb that I like to start with:

  1. Can you drop your interest rate by 1%-2%?
  2. Can you pay off your closing costs within a year or two? (Average closing costs range from 2% to 4% of the loan.)


For example, let us take a $200,000 30-year mortgage at 5% with a monthly payment of $1,074 (before taxes and insurance). If refinanced at 3%, we have an $843 monthly payment, or $231/month savings. And with closing costs of $4,000 (2% of the loan), it takes 17 months to break even ($4,000/$231). This is compelling. Not only does it drop the payment, but it only takes 17 months to break even on closing costs.


GET THE LATEST UPDATES: Download the free Tennessean app on your mobile device


As a note, while it may technically make sense on paper to refinance even if a break even is not reached within the first year or two, it can be difficult to predict the long term. For example, your job may change next year and you may decide to sell your house. This is why I usually encourage folks to refinance if they can break even in the short term.


There are many other things you may want to consider when refinancing, such as changing from a variable rate to fixed rate, locking in a shorter term, or changing the amount of the loan.


Every situation is different, so consider reaching out to a mortgage broker or financial adviser to see what makes sense for you.


Hunter Yarbrough, CPA, CFP, is an executive vice president and financial adviser with CapWealth. He is passionate about taking a holistic view of personal finance, including investments, taxes, retirement, education, estate planning, and insurance. For more information about Hunter and CapWealth, visit capwealthgroup.com.


Year-End client meeting with their wealth firm
By Hillary Stalker December 24, 2025
Reflecting on year-end means more than looking back. It’s about client reviews, strategy updates, and planning ahead for smarter financial outcomes.
An image showing someone pruning savings from minimizing capital gain taxes
By Blake Harrison December 6, 2025
CapWealth’s Blake Harrison shares advanced strategies to help high-net-worth investors minimize capital gains taxes in Forbes with William Baldwin.
By Hillary Stalker December 3, 2025
Financial advisors are not psychotherapists as CapWealth’s Hillary Stalker shares insights on setting healthy client boundaries in Financial Advisor.
An individual reviewing their finances changes to make for 2026
By Hillary Stalker December 2, 2025
Review your financial year in review and take advantage of key changes for 2026 to boost savings, maximize tax benefits, and start the new year strong.
A family around a table sharing what they are thankful for in this season of gratitude.
By CapWealth November 18, 2025
This season of gratitude, the CapWealth team reflects on client trust, meaningful relationships, and the privilege of helping others reach financial goals.
Holiday shopping receipts showing the impact of Giftflation
By Hillary Stalker November 12, 2025
Giftflation is squeezing budgets. CapWealth’s Hillary Stalker shares tips with NerdWallet on how to manage rising gift costs and stay financially grounded.
Financial advisor working with clients on their year-end giving strategy to maximize tax savings
By Jennifer Horton November 4, 2025
Plan your year-end giving to unlock meaningful impact, maximize tax savings, and take full advantage of strategic charitable tax benefits before December 31.
Tim Pagliara on Fox Business News
October 28, 2025
CapWealth CIO Tim Pagliara discusses the impact of technology earnings on free cash flow in Big Tech on 'The Claman Countdown.'
A couple is reviewing their year-end financial checklist to start the new year off right.
By Hillary Stalker October 21, 2025
This financial checklist covers retirement plans, taxes, and budgets so you can make smart money moves before year-end and start the new year with clarity.
Show More

Share Article